Comments on Pro Libertate: A Parasite's Priorities (Updated, February 23)

They are in power. They have the power, so, there ...

2011-09-14T10:22:38.608-06:00

They are in power. They have the power, so, there is nothing we can do.

Tax evasing was conceived by jews ("their" money w...

2008-05-20T00:10:00.000-06:00

Tax evasing was conceived by jews ("their" money were stolen from simple people)and for jews there are no laws, no moral, they could do everything, every crime, but other peple couldn't!

Excellent.

2008-02-29T18:45:00.000-07:00

Excellent.

Excellent post, as usual.

2008-02-29T14:31:00.000-07:00

Excellent post, as usual.

Dear Will,If this was Japan I would write to which...

2008-02-28T16:32:00.000-07:00

Dear Will,

If this was Japan I would write to whichever state employee is in charge of those things, and nominate you as a Living National Cultural Treasure. A wonderful essay, as always, and a most impressive forum of commentators.

Might I suggest a name for these public employees? Here it is: (Webster's New World Dictionary....)LEECH: "2. Any of a number of bloodsucking worms living in water or wet earth and used in medicine, esp. in former times, to bleed patients. 3.A person who clings to another to get some gain out of him; a parasite. 4. In medicine, a suction apparatus for drawing blood.

Come every April 15, I certainly feel lightheaded as if drained of blood and life energy, when I read my tax return and see how much these leeches have sucked from me to fund the mass murder of Iraqi children, the torture of taxi drivers and schoolteachers, the assassination of leaders duly elected and chosen by other groups of people, the economic subjection of billions of people all over the world, the destruction of our entire planet, and so on and on.

Actually, I suppose, given such enormous and impressive achievements, government is giving me quite a LOT for my rather limited monetary "contributions."

No - they do not take from us, we "contribute" to them and the purposes they have chosen for us, such as destruction of the planet we live on. Which is another of their talents - doublespeak. I remember many years ago when I got my very first parking ticket in life, and it read: "Opportunity To Pay a Fixed Penalty." As in, if I chose not to avail myself of this "opportunity" they were offering me, I could argue it before a judge and pay even more, plus court costs. Today, I really wish I had kept a Xerox copy of that ticket, but back then I was too young to appreciate the irony of it.

I would like to respond to "Dixiedog" who said: "Has it occurred to anyone that a majority of the commoners these days drink from the public trough?" This is true, but it is all part of the intentional design. Drain the people of all intiative by making them eternal infants, and encouraging them to suckle forever at the tit of government largesse. Make them into everlasting babies, carried everywhere in the strong arms of the State, and warned that trying to stand on their own two feet and take a step for themselves will result in falls and painful bruises. Yes, the majority have fallen for it. They want the State do look after them forever. But the State cannot. Remember 9-11? Remember Katrina? Tornadoes? Wildfires? Floods? Where was the State then? Nowhere. The victims suddenly had to stand alone, and did not like it.

I like the word "leech." Considering that leeches are blind, slimy creatures, live in fetid stinking swamps, and suck human blood, this pretty well describes them.

Best wishes,
Chris Taylor,
Arlington, VA

PS: The photo of Sgt.Schultz was marvelous. Why don't you send a copy to our poor hero Herr Zumwinkel. He could probably use a laugh right now.

Somalia is what you get when a state collapses.Hav...

2008-02-27T00:04:00.000-07:00

Somalia is what you get when a state collapses.

Have you ever heard of self-government, sebastian? Somalis have no record of self-government and so the result is predictable when no State is keeping the commoners in line, just as it would be with any society without a moral foundation and its attendant rule of law. Ergo, Somalia is what you get when you have rudderless culture without a State to provide that rudder, however arbitrary and secular that "rudder" may be.

Irresponsible management is what you get when the state doesn't make sure that people are held accountable for their actions.

By what you have said, it's obviously clear that you believe that folk cannot possibly be able to understand right and wrong without the State being the arbiter for that judgment.

You are a moral relativist and that's not surprising in the least, mind you, as most folk over here these days are also moral relativists and need (indeed require) a State authority to tell them which action is the "RIGHT" action and which is the "WRONG" one. Sad, sad...

It bothers me that commoners today look not to God, His Word, their own intuition, but rather to a government advisory, policy, or regulation - whether it pertains to weather, law, taxes, behavior, etc. - to guide how they will behave and conduct their lives. However, as I mentioned earlier, when so many folk get a large portion or all of their bread from government, the odds that they will act in defiance, even when called for, is slim to none.

IMHO, I think that's what Will may be overlooking in these matters.

"People are supposed to pay their taxes."No. Becau...

2008-02-26T16:10:00.000-07:00

"People are supposed to pay their taxes."

No. Because taking a person's property against their will is theft.
Therefore, taxes are theft. No one is supposed to cooperate with evil.
On the contrary, you are supposed to oppose evil.

Sebastian! Wow!Well said! My man, you gave me goos...

2008-02-26T00:36:00.000-07:00

Sebastian!
Wow!
Well said!
My man, you gave me goose pimples!
Everything within the state; nothing outside the state; nothing against the state.
I.....I.... love you.
Seig heil.

-Benito Hess-Gramsci

No somalia is what you get when you have a central...

2008-02-25T23:18:00.000-07:00

No somalia is what you get when you have a central govt. that is rife with corruption and cronyism. (the two are basically symbiotic)

People are supposed to pay their taxes. If you thi...

2008-02-25T22:09:00.000-07:00

People are supposed to pay their taxes. If you think they are too high, then go live some where else, or vote for someone who will reduce them. Secretly funneling your money out of the country to avoid paying your taxes is illegal. Zumwinkel may have done a good job with Deutsche Post, but that does not allow him to break the law. If he was not willing to pay that much tax, then he should have quit the job and gone to work for Liechtenstein's postal service.

I agree with your criticism regarding IKB. The problem with todays managers seems to be that they cash in large pay checks, dividends, pensions etc.; but are not held accountable for their mistakes, when they make them. For example the whole sub-prime thing. Your criticism regarding the state is exaggerated. The people in charge of the state and semi-state owned corporations belong to the same political elite that the manager come from. You Americans should know that by now. Rumsfeld and co all held or now hold positions in large corporations.

I'm aware that on the other side of the Atlantic you like to engage in socialist bashing, but it doesn't address the issue. There seems to be an alarming lack of responsibility in manager elites across the globe. It is not an ailment of a rampantly socialist Germany - we like to call it social capitalism. Your predatory capitalism has the same, if not worse issues.

Regarding your fervent anti-statism. It almost sounds anarchist-like, and they are on the left. State control is a necessity. Somalia is what you get when a state collapses. Irresponsible management is what you get when the state doesn't make sure that people are held accountable for their actions.

Will, I like your reference to Bastiat. He was a ...

2008-02-25T21:21:00.000-07:00

Will, I like your reference to Bastiat. He was a man of uncommon observation and an ability to put his thoughts to words. We could use a few like him in our time, and yes Ron Paul is probably such a man in my humble opinion.

Unfortunately, we are creatures of the economics of scarcity. All competing for the greatest amount of resources with the least amount of effort (and I think that is true of all of us, myself included, it is the nature of humanity). What tilts the natural balance is government attempting to manipulate our interactions - which only amplifies the underlying 'greed' motive. And none amongst our species are worse in their greed motive than those who wear the official government label . . .

Czechs seem to regard their government as a mildly...

2008-02-25T20:04:00.000-07:00

Czechs seem to regard their government as a mildly tractable, infinitely gullible, only occaisionally useful cow, one which could sometimes be coaxed into giving milk but which was mostly best left alone. Dim beast, that, with poor eyesight and an uncertain temper. Those folks lived with the Soviets for thirty years; they -remember- where all this nonsense leads. The police are an amiable combination of lazy, underpaid, and corrupt, with a leavening of a few serious pros to handle the few truly difficult cases. Nobody waves their casual breaking of the law in the cops' faces, and they don't make themselves more offensive than to fish for a bribe on occasion. To be labeled an informer is always trouble, doubly so since becoming an informer over there means crossing not only some pretty nasty people, but total ostracism from the community. Accordingly, turncoats are few, and mostly limited to the nasty folks aforementioned; organized crime figures and the like. The Roma, of course, -never- talk to cops. About anything.

I lived in Prague from August of '06 to August of '07. It was a tremendous eye-opener: a sickening irony that in what was once an Iron Curtain nation, everyday life is vastly freer from lethal and inconvenient harassment by the State. Surveillance cameras in the Metro, for instance, are the constant targets of vandalism and pranks, take months to be replaced, and are not watched anyway since the various Police Departments can't spare the manpower. People over there aren't afraid of the Police all the time, as in the US, and on the rare occaisions when the Czech cops -do- overreact (as in the infamous case of CzechTek, a Techno festival broken up with riot police) heads roll. The CzechTek incident helped fire a Prime Minister, which in turn left the country without a functioning Federal-level government for seven months. Country got on just fine. The rest of the E.U. thought it was a joke; the Czechs thought it was a bargain. They seemed to think that paying politicians to sit at home and do nothing was at least a workable alternative to paying them to actually -do- something. Their concerns seemed mostly to revolve around keeping this or that party or individual from doing "something" about this issue or that (notably American anti-missile radars), and paying the buggers to sit home and sleep late was starting to look like a neat means of accomplishing this.

We have lawyer jokes? They have cop jokes, and a more abusive, profane, satirical, embarassing magnificent body of humour you will not find.

Magnificent country. Getting back to the U.S. has been a nasty culture shock. Same thing happened when I came back from Ireland.

I wonder if it's a pattern?

Anonymous said:The only thing left to export from ...

2008-02-25T10:12:00.000-07:00

Anonymous said:

The only thing left to export from this country are our raw resources - timber/oil/ metals. How far this great nation has fallen.

Don't forget stupidity, the most plentiful (if least marketable) of all American exports.

Fabio Bossi said:

Germans don`t even know anymore what the word "freedom" means.

From my extensive travels in that country, as well as encounters with Germans here in Amerika, I'm hard pressed to believe that the average German would recognize "freedom" if it bite them in the nose. Germany has ALWAYS been a regimented, regulated society and the average German's outlook on the State, and the individual's (to the extent that Germans recognize the individual as significant at all) relationship to it reflects this.

Please Americans, elect Ron Paul and save us again...

2008-02-25T06:32:00.000-07:00

Please Americans, elect Ron Paul and save us again!
We won`t achieve it on our own. Germans don`t even know anymore what the word "freedom" means.

Cheerio from Munich

Fabio
bavaria-for-ron-paul.blogspot.com

steve, thanks for your comments. As to which laws ...

2008-02-25T04:21:00.000-07:00

steve, thanks for your comments.

As to which laws we are morally obliged to obey -- the law "thou shalt not steal" is one of universal and unqualified application. Who is stealing here -- the honest man who accumulates wealth, or the government that plunders half or more of an honest man's earnings, and its retinue of parasites?

This situation is one Bastiat addressed, and I'll try to paraphrase what I think his reaction would be to the non-crime of tax "evasion":

When the law has become perverted, it is not the moral obligation of citizens to accommodate it. Rather, it is the moral obligation of the government to bring its enactments into harmony with the law (using that expression in its proper sense).

Tax "evasion" is the natural and morally healthy reaction of citizens to a regime that behaves just as you describe: It picks and chooses which laws it will follow in order to enrich some at the expense of others.

That is the variety of anarchy that does most of the real damage in the world.

If people meekly submit to that variety of lawless government, no useful changes will ever result. It may be imprudent to do as Zumwinkel and others have done, I grant, just as the same can be said of "tax resisters" in this country (given our heritage, shouldn't all of us be tax resisters of one form or another?). But I can't see how trying to keep what one has honestly earned is immoral.

You make a lot of good points. However, if every ...

2008-02-25T00:48:00.000-07:00

You make a lot of good points. However, if every German were to decide which laws apply to him, and which ones don't, all hell would break loose. Instead of defending Zumwinkel, why not argue that the Germans need to drop their pie in the sky conceptions of economics and adopt laws that actually help their country.

anonymous says I said this: Dixiedog's assertion t...

2008-02-24T01:13:00.000-07:00

anonymous says I said this: Dixiedog's assertion that real meaningful change is 'Nonsense. Illogical. It can't and won't happen.'

...and he disagrees with that. Fine, but at the very least quote the totality of what I said.

For instance, you certainly didn't quote anything remotely even resembling what I wrote other than the "Nonsense..." phrase:

How do we logically expect that we can somehow, miraculously if you will, trim down the reach of government when so many commoners are desiring to expand it, despite their collective claims to the contrary??

Nonsense. Illogical. It can't and won't happen.

Now, that's what I wrote, NOT "real meaningful change is..." To put what I said in a different, but similar, context: Does one act in opposition to his boss, or otherwise does what he pleases, while simultaneously demanding he get his paycheck? Nah, Of course not. He might try it and he's fired (no more income).

So there's a clear dichotomy between those, a majority of the populace, who claim to "loathe" government, while at THE SAME TIME are essentially parasites, to various degrees, receiving some kind of government income, either from working for government directly, as a contractor indirectly, or simply receiving a subsidy in some form, i.e. farmers, et al.

For yet another example, a kid can't demand his/her allowance from her parents while he/she likewise rebels against daddy and his rules. He/she can rather expect to receive no allowance.

That's what's illogical. Is it clearer, anonymous? Perhaps, you can see what I'm sayin' now.

I have to disagree with Dixiedog's assertion that ...

2008-02-23T22:34:00.000-07:00

I have to disagree with Dixiedog's assertion that real meaningful change is 'Nonsense. Illogical. It can't and won't happen.' If that were the case, this country would still be a British colony. However, enough of the 'right people', not necessarily a majority (there were many supporters of the crown during the first revolution), need to be willing to commit that change.

One of the ways we have available to us is to use the tactics of those we oppose - starting with language - against them. There was a time in this country when bureaucrats were rightly looked down on in society as parasites, a time when the constabulary was required to walk the streets and know the people and a time when government recognized that it was a beggar class. They weren't public servants and they weren't lionized.

Using language to change the culture is a start and calling these people parasites, as they are, is a good way to start.

I certainly agree with your article, but I still h...

2008-02-23T18:46:00.000-07:00

I certainly agree with your article, but I still have to add, that I can't feel too much pity towards Zumwinkel.
He is/was good buddies with the political class and recently supported and pushed a bill enacting a minimum wage (12-14$ per hour depending on the region) for postal services to protect the monopoly of the Deutsche Post in this sector.

Sixty-three years after the war ended, Germany rem...

2008-02-23T08:52:00.000-07:00

Sixty-three years after the war ended, Germany remains an occupied nation. It presents a facade of national sovereignty. Yet its territory (Ramstein air force base) serves as a base for U.S. aggression; its armed forces are goaded into the NATO mission in Afghanistan despite popular opposition; and, Germany subserviently joined the US/UK-initiated War on Tax Havens.

Dixiedog has got it right: by promoting the brazen lie that every employee has an 'account' with Social Security, the evil genius Frank Roosevelt transformed the MAJORITY of the population overnight into swillers at the public trough. It will be exceedingly difficult after three generations to remove this poisoned chalice. The involuntary intervention of national bankruptcy is probably the only way.

Today's conventional wisdom that 'democracy' is the ne plus ultra of political systems is deeply flawed. In fact, democracy coupled with an elastic fiat currency is a sure prescription for disaster. Its powerful incentives to imprudence guarantee eventual ruin. Too bad the failed 'science' of economics is unable to diagnose this fatal malady.

Very good Will. I agree with your take on the matt...

2008-02-22T22:58:00.000-07:00

Very good Will. I agree with your take on the matter, but I think you, perhaps inadvertently, omit certain facts about the people involved in government. After all, government is an entity made up of people who likewise live in the state in question.

Has it occurred to anyone that a majority of the commoners these days drink from the public trough? That's NOT merely a naked assertion. Once again (like it really needs repeating...sigh), but some just don't grok it, apparently: Government is an approximate mirror reflection of the aggregate society. It's not a precise reflection, but how precise does it need to be to see the dichotomy of a "love" "loathe" government relationship that MOST folk harbor? How do we logically expect that we can somehow, miraculously if you will, trim down the reach of government when so many commoners are desiring to expand it, despite their collective claims to the contrary??

Nonsense. Illogical. It can't and won't happen.

It's not that there are a tiny ravenous quantity of parasites that merely need to be innoculated against, but rather there are huge quantity of ravenous parasites, a majority of the population, instead. As for hosts, if there's not a "tiny," certainly it's a small, quantity of those hapless souls.

Good rant, Will, but we have to take into account and expose the entire picture of what's really happenin', even if it's PAINFUL to do so, if there's to be any hope of a radical change. Freedom doesn't just grow on trees or simply transpire out of thin air by bunch of idealistic youngsters screaming "Freeeeeeeeeeeeeedom!" Sigh...NO!

THE commoners themselves have to want it (REALLY WANT IT!), that is the accountability and responsibility attendant to it, for true freedom to be workable in society.

I suspect you well know the reality, Will, but nevertheless, sometimes I think your message seems to try to paint "government" and "the people" as somehow hostile entities to one another.

NO! NO! Heck NO! If only that WERE true, we would see a sea change in government quick time.

Of course, I could be misreading your inferences, but that's largely what I infer often from your varied pieces.

I realized many years ago, during my Naval service...

2008-02-22T21:58:00.000-07:00

I realized many years ago, during my Naval service, that the state views me as a milk cow to be used at it sees fit. My view since has been to internationialize myself as much as possible. Citizenship in one country, my investments in another, a crib outside the US, and a bank account in dare I say, a tax haven. Since the US has become a national security state, for our safety of course, I fully suspect that when the crap hits the fan (terror attack, economic dislocation, will of the next Nero) they are going to lock this place down like one of their rendition sites. If you aint got out by then you aint gettin out. It always pays to be prepared. Another outstanding article.

The infrastructure is crumbling _ roads full of po...

2008-02-22T21:49:00.000-07:00

The infrastructure is crumbling _ roads full of potholes and cracks- yet the state police, DOT and various other government agencies are always seen driving around in the newest brands of vehicles decked out with cutting edge high tech gear. Increasingly I feel as though we are living in a third world country. When will the madness and financial blood sucking end. There is very little left to take. The USA reminds me of the turkey served for dinner in National Lampoon's Christmas vacation. Looking good on the outside but scratch below the surface and what is their ... a hollow empty carcass. The only thing left to export from this country are our raw resources - timber/oil/ metals. How far this great nation has fallen.

In my own search for personal understanding of the...

2008-02-22T20:55:00.000-07:00

In my own search for personal understanding of the circumstances we commonly refer to as government I've gone through many personally used epitaphs to describe the 'ruling class'. Statist, socialist, fascist all failed in some fundamental way to fully encompass what I was witnessing. Eventually, I too use the word 'parasite' to describe these misbegotten elements of society because it is the most accurate scientific term available. I have used it in a couple prior comments to your blog (and though I am pleased to see you see fit to use it also, wouldn't presume to feel I may have influenced that choice of words).

I do, however, think it is appropriate to reflect a moment on that well chosen choice of words as I feel it most is a most accurate descriptive word for anyone with their snout in the tax trough.

Science often attempts to classify observations based on attributes and when one steps back to look at the relationship to those in government (that's anyone getting a pay check from a government agency) and the remainder of society one is naturally led to the parasite/host relationship.

In biology, we know that there are beneficial parasitic organisms and there are detrimental organisms. But even the beneficial ones, when their existence is detrimental to the host, generate one of two possible outcomes; the host suffers/dies or the parasites are eliminated. Our relationship to our current governance is at this crossroad and we have to decide - are we a parasite or a host and which will prevail.

The very nature of government is to obfuscate its actions by so many layers of bureaucracy that even (especially?) those who are the ones to implement its machinations can not see it. Those parasitic people now outnumber the hosts of this pathological society. If they are not eliminated, the host dies. If the host retaliates it will be weakened and may die. However, if the host survives purging itself of its parasitic infestation it may survive to enjoy its existence a bit longer than it would have.

That is our dilemma . . . eliminate the parasites, either remove or destroy them, or die . . .

Wonderfully penetrating article. There is a main-s...

2008-02-22T20:39:00.000-07:00

Wonderfully penetrating article. There is a main-stream article out of the San Fran Chronicle that you might find interesting Will. It's called "Rule of Law, or Rule by Fear." Pretty freaky if you ask me. What are they up to? Just making money I hope?