Comments on Pro Libertate: The Right to Resist: Will Michigan Repeal the "Rapist Doctrine"?

I was unaware that the state could simply make a n...

2012-02-03T11:40:22.146-07:00

I was unaware that the state could simply make a new law to overturn a right recognized by the USSC in Bad Elk.

Unfortunately in New York State the 'law' ...

2011-12-19T21:59:55.253-07:00

Unfortunately in New York State the 'law' specifically does not allow resistance of any arrest. I quote

S 35.27 Justification; use of physical force in resisting arrest prohibied.
A person may not use physical force to resist an arrest, whether
authorized or unauthorized, which is being effected or attempted by a
police officer or peace officer when it would reasonably appear that the
latter is a police officer or peace officer.

This really sucks because NYC has the worlds most militarized over the top out of control SS.

What's the big problemo with unlawful search??...

2011-12-17T20:27:16.388-07:00

What's the big problemo with unlawful search?? I don't get it. They ARE the police and can lie, beat, and hammer their way to justice. My God..where's Himmler when you need him? He had the answers to all these whining complaints.

I am tired of this belief that most Americans have...

2011-12-11T21:10:16.312-07:00

I am tired of this belief that most Americans have that police are gods. And because they are gods they can do anything and everything they want. The truth is the police are hardly gods, and they are just as likely, if not much more likely, to commit crimes than anyone else.

Mr. Grigg A "contradiction in terms" is...

2011-12-09T16:22:19.653-07:00

Mr. Grigg

A "contradiction in terms" is not synonymous with "oxymoron." An oxymoron is, in fact, a seeming contradiction that is surprisingly true.

@ William JD -- What you're referring to is be...

2011-12-09T13:15:34.787-07:00

@ William JD -- What you're referring to is best described as an abduction, rather than an arrest. I've typically referred to the "right to resist unlawful arrest," which, as you point out, incorporates an oxymoron. It would be more accurate to refer to the right to resist official abduction, perhaps.

I opened up my Black's Law Dictionary, and the...

2011-12-09T13:07:00.297-07:00

I opened up my Black's Law Dictionary, and the definition of "arrest" begins with the following:

"To deprive a person of his liberty by legal authority."

An "unlawful arrest" is a contradiction in terms! It's an incoherent concept!

The topmost photo is indeed disgusting. If you ha...

2011-12-09T06:15:37.193-07:00

The topmost photo is indeed disgusting. If you haven't already noticed the goon with his arm out looks to be holding something like mace. And they have the prototypical buzz cuts. I swear! If there isn't a clearer sign of fleas on these mad dogs.

That photo of the woman at the top of the page – I...

2011-12-08T16:34:15.136-07:00

That photo of the woman at the top of the page – I remember that and used to have larger photos showing it at different angles; the cops completely destroyed her knee, and her foot seemed close to her face, yet look at the cops – one of them has her by the wrist as if he is going to handcuff her. And the other cops are keeping people away from her; “crowd control,” I guess. I was enraged when I saw that.

Of course, she had to be carried away from there in an ambulance and, if I recall, she had to have several surgeries on her knee. I’m pretty sure it wasn’t the cops who summoned medical help; they seemed not to notice that her leg was bent forward in such a sickening, abnormal way. I saw another picture of her in a courtroom, in a wheelchair, with her heavily bandaged leg propped outward. Whether her knee was ever the same, I don’t know. Do you know her name? I’d like to look it up. THOSE ANIMALS – could they not make one exception to the rule of handcuffing her and pretending that she was somehow fighting back and call for an ambulance? She was obviously seriously injured, perhaps unconscious from the pain. BUT NO. They have a script from which they never waver – grab the wrists, FLAY THE WRISTS AROUND THEMSELVES, as though the person is doing it, as “proof” that the person is fighting, or “resisting.”

I’ve shown these photos to several people and the reaction I get is NOTHING. Maybe they think “she must have done something to deserve it.”

I believe I’ve mentioned this before, but I saw a video of a man in prison, an old black man that the cops were beating and tasing and shouting “Stop resisting!” At the end a cop yelled “Stop re–...” He couldn’t finish the command, because the man was already dead and had been dead for awhile.

It's all about the State wanting to corral the...

2011-12-08T09:38:04.097-07:00

It's all about the State wanting to corral the public into their sheep pens. YOU, citizen/slave, are not to question nor resist their supremacy. To do so would, in our present day Leninist overlords' minds, constitute an "existential threat". The laws being rammed through Congress are to pave the way to justify past, present and forthcoming abuse by goose-stepping LEO's and their more than happy to enable legal beagles.

Or did they mean that this doctrine was dangerous ...

2011-12-08T08:53:08.781-07:00

Or did they mean that this doctrine was dangerous to those who would illegallly arrest people[?]

Yes, that's exactly what they mean. Anything that challenges the implied supremacy of the State over the individual is, in the minds of the Ruling Classes, inherently "dangerous."

How exactly is the right to resist illegal arrest ...

2011-12-08T03:03:35.533-07:00

How exactly is the right to resist illegal arrest "dangerous and outmoded"? It is not at all safe to allow someone who wants to illegally detain you to do so. What great advance in ensuring bodily integrity and safety has made self-defence "outmoded"?

Or did they mean that this doctrine was dangerous to those who would illegallly arrest people. I did not know that the law took any notice of how dangerous crime was for the criminal.

no need to post Greetings Will, Shared Thank yo...

2011-12-06T15:31:43.624-07:00

no need to post

Greetings Will,

Shared

Thank you for writing this essay

Doc Ellis 124

no need to post